Book Review: The Oxford Handbook of International Law in Asia and the Pacific

Edited by: Simon Chesterman, Hisashi Owada, and Ben Saul
Publisher: Oxford University Press, 2019
ISBN: 978-0-19-879385-4

Introduction

The Oxford Handbook of International Law in Asia and the Pacific is a significant contribution to the field of international law, offering an in-depth examination of legal issues specific to the Asian and Pacific regions. Edited by three distinguished scholars, Simon Chesterman, Hisashi Owada, and Ben Saul, this volume presents a comprehensive exploration of how international legal principles are interpreted, applied, and sometimes resisted across diverse legal and political landscapes.

Summary of Content

The book is structured into three major parts:

1. Themes, Institutions, and History – This section provides an overarching perspective on Asia’s engagement with international law. It explores historical interactions, regional institutions, and the broader theoretical underpinnings that influence the development of legal norms in the region.
2. Specialized Branches of International Law – This portion of the book delves into specific areas of law such as human rights, environmental law, maritime disputes, economic law, and international criminal law. Each chapter critically assesses how these areas are shaped by regional politics and global influences.
3. International Law in Asian and Pacific States – The final section presents country-specific analyses, highlighting the distinct ways international law is received and implemented in nations such as China, Japan, India, Australia, and the Pacific Island states. These case studies illustrate both convergence and divergence in legal practices across the region.

Strengths

✅ Comprehensive Coverage: The handbook brings together a diverse range of topics, offering a thorough analysis of both foundational and contemporary legal issues in Asia and the Pacific.
✅ Expert Contributions: Featuring chapters written by leading scholars, the book provides authoritative perspectives on complex legal matters.
✅ Regional Specificity: Unlike many international law texts that focus predominantly on Western perspectives, this book offers a much-needed focus on Asia and the Pacific, giving voice to legal traditions and institutions that are often overlooked.
✅ Interdisciplinary Approach: The book effectively integrates historical, political, and economic contexts, making it a valuable resource for scholars from multiple disciplines.

Limitations

❌ Technical Complexity: Some sections of the book are highly specialized and may be challenging for readers without a strong background in international law.
❌ Limited Practical Application: While the book is rich in theoretical analysis, practitioners seeking practical legal guidance may find fewer concrete case studies than desired.

Conclusion

The Oxford Handbook of International Law in Asia and the Pacific is an essential reference for academics, legal practitioners, and policymakers interested in the intersection of international law and regional dynamics. Its in-depth analysis, regional focus, and expert insights make it an invaluable addition to legal scholarship. While the book’s complexity may pose a challenge for general readers, its scholarly contributions ensure its place as a cornerstone text in the field.

Rating: 5/5 for scholars and researchers, 4/5 for general readers.