Is Hindutva Dictating Indian Media?
Following an attack in Kulgam, segments of Indian television immediately pointed fingers at Pakistan before forensic evidence or credible investigations emerged. The rush to amplify unverified...
A matchstick can start a fire, but it takes someone willing to pour petrol to turn it into a national crisis. In the world of Indian television, a security incident can quickly become something much bigger: a political headline, a national security debate and, sometimes, an accusation against Pakistan. Before investigators establish the facts, television screens can already have a culprit. The Kulgam incident is another example of how quickly a developing security story can become part of India’s familiar anti-Pakistan media narrative.
On November 11, 2026, an attack on a Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) checkpoint in Kulgam, Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir, injured three personnel. The incident deserved serious investigation and responsible reporting. However, the response of certain Indian media outlets raises a different question: why does Pakistan become the centre of the story before publicly established evidence confirms any connection?
A promotional post by CNN News18 on November 12 provides a revealing example. Under the headline, “Pakistan’s desperate attempt to derail Naya J&K,” the channel presented Pakistan as responsible for the incident. The wording did not invite an investigation or acknowledge uncertainty. Instead, it offered viewers a ready-made conclusion. This is precisely where journalism begins to lose its distinction from political messaging.
The problem is not that Indian media reports on security incidents or examines possible cross-border connections. Responsible journalism must investigate every credible lead. The problem emerges when an allegation is presented as an established fact, without explaining the evidence, identifying its source or allowing an investigation to reach its conclusion.
An Old Script With a Familiar Target
The Pakistan-blaming approach is not new in Indian television coverage. Whenever a security incident takes place, sections of the Indian media quickly turn towards Pakistan, often using dramatic language and national security rhetoric. The familiar pattern is to circulate allegations, repeat them across television discussions and create an atmosphere in which questioning the accusation becomes difficult.
This approach is particularly visible in the television ecosystem aligned with the political messaging of the Hindutva regime. Instead of separating verified information from political interpretation, some channels turn security incidents into opportunities to reinforce an existing narrative about Pakistan.
The News18 headline is important because it does not merely report an incident. It assigns political meaning to it. The phrase “desperate attempt” suggests that Pakistan is already established as the actor behind the attack, while “derail Naya J&K” connects the incident to a broader political storyline. The audience is therefore encouraged to interpret the event through a predetermined political framework rather than wait for evidence.
From Social Media Allegations to Television Headlines
Another concern is the relationship between social media narratives and mainstream television coverage. Unverified claims can circulate rapidly online, gain attention through repeated sharing and then become subjects of television discussions. Once prominent channels repeat such claims, audiences may begin to mistake repetition for confirmation.
This creates a dangerous cycle. An allegation becomes a headline, the headline becomes a television debate, and the debate creates the impression that the accusation has already been established. Yet repetition does not turn an allegation into evidence.
In the Kulgam case, the question should be straightforward: what independently verified evidence establishes Pakistan’s involvement? Who has presented that evidence? Has an investigation established the alleged connection, or are television channels simply repeating an accusation?
These are basic journalistic questions, not political objections. A responsible news organisation should be willing to answer them.
Turning Security Incidents Into Political Opportunities
There is also a wider political dimension. IIOJK remains a politically sensitive region, with unresolved questions surrounding political representation, governance and the restoration of statehood. In such an environment, security incidents can easily become part of larger political messaging.
The use of Pakistan as a recurring subject in domestic political discussions can shift public attention towards an external enemy instead of encouraging debate about internal challenges. This does not mean every security report has a political motive. It does, however, make editorial independence and careful verification particularly important.
When television coverage repeatedly connects domestic security incidents with Pakistan without presenting sufficient evidence, it risks replacing public accountability with political polarisation.
The Difference Between Journalism and Propaganda
The Kulgam incident should be investigated through forensic evidence, credible intelligence, witness accounts and a transparent process. Pakistan’s security sources have rejected the allegations being circulated against the country. Such denials, like accusations, must be assessed through evidence rather than accepted or dismissed automatically.
Equally, the attack on CRPF personnel should not become an excuse to manufacture hostility against an entire country. Security reporting requires restraint, verification and a clear distinction between suspicion and established responsibility.
Pakistan should not become the automatic answer to every security question arising in India. An allegation is not proof, a headline is not an investigation, and repeated accusations are not evidence. If Indian media wants public trust, it must establish facts before assigning blame.




