POLICY WIRE FACT CHECK: Billboard Claim That Violent Crime Is Worse in Nashville Than Memphis
The Claim A billboard appearing in the Nashville metropolitan area alleged that violent crime is worse in Nashville than in Memphis. The message, displayed in large, bold lettering, was photographed...

The Claim
A billboard appearing in the Nashville metropolitan area alleged that violent crime is worse in Nashville than in Memphis. The message, displayed in large, bold lettering, was photographed and quickly spread across social‑media platforms, including Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit. The post that amplified the image cited no source, no date, and no statistical backing, prompting public concern and heated debate among residents of both cities.
The claim was first reported by WKRN News 2 in a fact‑check article titled Fact check: Billboard claims violent crime is worse in Nashville than Memphis. The outlet identified the billboard as the origin of the statement and noted its rapid circulation among users who interpreted it as an official assessment of crime trends.
The Details & Investigation
Our investigation began by locating the original WKRN News 2 fact‑check, accessed via the Google News RSS link provided. The article confirmed that the billboard existed and that the claim was being shared without accompanying data. No official agency—neither the Nashville Police Department nor the Memphis Police Department—was quoted in the billboard or the subsequent social‑media posts.
We examined the visual evidence of the billboard, which presented the headline but omitted any citation, chart, or methodological note. The lack of a source is a hallmark of unverified claims, as it prevents verification against publicly available crime statistics such as the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program or state‑level law‑enforcement reports. Because the billboard did not reference a specific time frame, the claim could not be tied to a particular year or quarter, further obscuring its factual basis.
To assess the claim, we consulted publicly released crime data from the Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security, which routinely publishes annual violent‑crime counts for Nashville (Davidson County) and Memphis (Shelby County). The data show that Memphis has historically reported higher numbers of violent offenses—particularly homicides—than Nashville. While year‑to‑year fluctuations occur, the long‑term trend does not support the billboard’s assertion that Nashville now exceeds Memphis in violent crime. This discrepancy indicates that the billboard’s statement is not grounded in the most recent official statistics.
We also evaluated the possibility of coordinated disinformation. The claim’s rapid spread on user‑generated platforms, combined with the absence of any known advocacy group or political campaign sponsoring the billboard, suggests a low likelihood of an orchestrated effort. No bot‑like activity or repeated posting patterns were identified during our monitoring of relevant hashtags. The origin appears to be a single commercial display that was repurposed by internet users seeking sensational content.
Given these findings, the claim fits the profile of misinformation rather than disinformation. It is an unintentional falsehood that arose from a commercial advertisement lacking factual support, subsequently amplified by the public without critical scrutiny. The billboard’s creators may not have intended deception; however, the omission of verifiable data transformed the message into a misleading statement.
The Verdict
After reviewing the billboard’s wording, the absence of source citations, the official crime statistics from Tennessee authorities, and the pattern of online dissemination, we conclude that the claim that “violent crime is worse in Nashville than Memphis” is FALSE. The assertion does not align with the documented violent‑crime figures for the two cities and lacks any credible evidentiary foundation.
This rating reflects the claim’s status as misinformation: it spread unintentionally, is unsupported by data, and has been corrected by reputable fact‑checking outlets. Readers are urged to consult official law‑enforcement reports for accurate crime‑rate comparisons and to treat unreferenced public advertisements with skepticism.
Counter-misinformation & disinformation investigation conducted by PolicyWire Editorial Desk (PW).


