Man Faces Return to Prison After Supreme Court Ruling on First Step Act
A freed man could be sent back to prison after a Supreme Court decision narrowed compassionate release options under the First Step Act.
POLICY WIRE — Washington, United States — A man who spent 13 years in prison for a nonviolent drug offense is now at risk of being sent back behind bars after a Supreme Court decision limited his chances for early release.
Patrick Dewayne Smith, 47, was released in 2024 under the First Step Act, a landmark criminal justice reform law. However, a recent Supreme Court ruling has put his freedom in jeopardy, as it determined that sentencing disparities from past laws are not sufficient grounds for compassionate release.
Smith, who has been working two jobs and rebuilding his life in Tennessee, now faces the possibility of a life sentence. His case highlights the ongoing debate over how to apply criminal justice reforms to those already serving long sentences.
Reporting by Policy-Wire (PW)





