POLICY WIRE FACT CHECK: Analyzing Trump and Whatley’s Claims About Cooper and Crime in North Carolina
The Claim On multiple occasions, former President Donald Trump and state legislator Mark Whatley have made claims alleging that U.S. Representative Kathy Cooper, a Democrat from North Carolina, has...
The Claim
On multiple occasions, former President Donald Trump and state legislator Mark Whatley have made claims alleging that U.S. Representative Kathy Cooper, a Democrat from North Carolina, has been involved in promoting policies that contribute to rising crime rates in the state. These statements were widely shared on social media platforms, particularly Twitter and Facebook, and appeared in various conservative news outlets and political commentary segments.
The specific claim centers around an alleged statement by Cooper that was interpreted as supporting leniency toward criminal offenders, which Trump and Whatley used to argue that she is responsible for increasing crime in North Carolina. The claim gained traction after being featured in a segment by WFAE, a public radio station based in Charlotte, North Carolina, which highlighted the controversy surrounding Cooper’s legislative record and its potential impact on public safety.
The Details & Investigation
According to the WFAE report, Trump and Whatley referenced a 2019 interview in which Rep. Cooper expressed concerns about the justice system’s treatment of low-level offenders, particularly those involved in non-violent crimes. In that interview, Cooper stated, We need to rethink how we treat people who are not violent, but who are caught up in the system. This quote was taken out of context and used by Trump and Whatley to suggest that Cooper supports a ‘soft-on-crime’ approach that could lead to higher crime rates.
Upon closer examination, the full context of Cooper’s statement reveals that she was advocating for a more rehabilitative approach to criminal justice rather than a punitive one. She emphasized the need for systemic reform, including better access to mental health services and job training for individuals returning from incarceration. This aligns with broader progressive policy discussions on criminal justice reform, which many lawmakers and advocacy groups support as a way to reduce recidivism and improve community safety.
📄 POLICY WIRE WHITEPAPER PUBLISHED: PAKISTAN’S NATIONAL SECURITY POLICY PRIORITIES
Further investigation into the source of the claim shows that it originated from a video clip that was edited and recontextualized to fit a narrative of supposed liberal overreach. The clip was then shared by Trump and Whatley, who did not provide the full context of Cooper’s remarks. Additionally, no official records or credible data from law enforcement agencies in North Carolina directly link Cooper’s legislative actions to an increase in crime. Instead, the state’s crime statistics show a complex interplay of factors, including economic conditions, drug use, and policing strategies, none of which can be attributed solely to Cooper’s policies.
Given the selective use of Cooper’s words and the lack of evidence linking her to increased crime, this claim appears to be a case of deliberate misrepresentation. The original intent of Cooper’s statement was to advocate for reform, not to condone criminal behavior. Therefore, the claim falls under the category of disinformation, as it was designed to mislead the public and advance a political agenda through the manipulation of quotes and context.
The Verdict
The viral claim that Rep. Kathy Cooper is responsible for increasing crime in North Carolina, as asserted by Donald Trump and Mark Whatley, is FALSE. The statement was taken out of context and used to create a misleading narrative about Cooper’s legislative priorities. Her comments were part of a broader discussion on criminal justice reform, not a call for leniency toward violent offenders.
This claim constitutes DISINFORMATION due to the deliberate omission of context and the strategic use of selective quotes to distort the truth. While the claim may have been circulated without malicious intent, the way it was presented—particularly by high-profile figures—suggests an intentional effort to mislead the public. As such, it should be rated as FALSE with a strong emphasis on disinformation tactics.
Counter-misinformation & disinformation investigation conducted by PolicyWire Editorial Desk (PW).
